Dancer’s Notes and Quotes

Entries from December 2005

Ramsey on Witsius

December 29, 2005 · No Comments

Herman Witsius on the Mosaic Covenant

Herman Witsius is used by Klineans to support their views. But he did not teach that the Mosaic covenant contained a works principle. It contains a restatement of the covenant of works, but the principle is not the condition of the covenant. It was given to teach them about their sin and need.

He taught that God did not require perfect legal obedience, but with sincerity of heart and repentance there would be temporal and spiritual blessings.

The basis of this is the covenant of grace. However the MC did not have the power for obedience, but the NC does. This is the basis of the difference.

The MC contained there was a repetition of the precepts, condition and curse in order to highlight sin.

Witsius saw this MC as a third covenant containing aspects of the CoG and CoW but without the power of the CoG.

Categories: ,

Categories: Uncategorized

Lusk - Why the Law/Gospel Paradigm Is Flawed

December 29, 2005 · No Comments

WHY THE LAW/GOSPEL PARADIGM IS FLAWED

Law/gospel comes from Luther. Calvin paid lip service to it and this has led to disaster.

This article deals with the nature of the Mosaic covenant.

Several points:

  1. The covenant did not annul the earlier covenant with Abraham.
  2. The law was given to an already redeemed Israel.
  3. The law was given to sinners and did not require perfect obedience. One could be a law-keeper without 100% perfect obedience.
  4. The sacrificial system offered a remedy for sin, at least typologically.
  5. The law was a revelation of the gospel - a shadow of the things to come.
  6. The various summaries of the law was not legalistic. Mic 6:8, Mt 23:23, Hab 2:4.
  7. That the law was received with fear and trembling does not mean that it was a works program.
  8. Warnings against apostasy are not against its gracious character.
  9. Jesus is not contrasted with Moses absolutely. Rather Jesus is a greater version of Moses. Matthew sees Jesus’ life as a fulfilment of Moses’ life.
  10. Torah is not a brownie point system. It is fatherly instruction. Too much of our thinking about the law is conditioned by Roman thought.

Calvin saw compatibility of Law and gospel in Inst. II.10. They are not two ways of salvation, but two phases of redemptive history.

WCF 7.5,6 supports this view.

Norman Shepherd takes this view too.

Conclusion: The NC is the OC in mature form.

Categories: , ,

Categories: Uncategorized

R Lusk - Jesus’ Baptism: The Fount of Life

December 21, 2005 · No Comments

Jesus’ baptism identifies him with us. When we are baptised we identify with him. He received the eschatological baptism of the Spirit. When we are baptised we share in the gift.

1. Heaven opened and the Holy Spirit came upon Jesus at his baptism.

“God anointed God with God”

The event is both trinitarian and eschatological. It is a turning point in history.

Baptism by water and Spirit are seen to be one act. At pentecost it is one (Acts 2:38). [Lusk even takes Paul's word in 1 Cor 12:13 as water baptism!]

John’s baptism was rooted in the Mosaic system. The Spirit could not be given with the same fulness.

The place of the baptism has symbolism. The wilderness: the exile. The Jordan: place of entry into the promised land. Baptism therefore is the place of second exodus - forgiveness of sins, preparation to meet God.

Spirit, water, voice - New Creation.

Dove - renewed world after the flood, sign of peace with God in the Mosaic system - foreshadows his coming death, which was also described as a baptism.

Jesus’ baptism begins the opening of the way for his people to heaven. Ripping of the temple curtain. [Lusk makes much of the water in creation as a kind of curtain between heaven and earth - fulfilment of Isa. 64:1]

What was begun at his baptism was completed at the cross and at Pentecost.

Our baptism brings the spirit’s descent and our ascent into the heavenly places.

2. At his baptism, a voice spoke from heaven, “This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.”
Some of these words taken from an enthronement liturgy in Ps 2. Jesus’ baptism is the claiming of his crown.
The other words come from Gen 22:2 “beloved son”. Jesus the new Isaac.

“in whom I delight” - Isa 42:1. The suffering servant - the new exodus. This is how we are to understand references to “servant” in the synoptics.

Three images - king, servant, sacrifice - to explain Jesus’ identity.

In our baptism God says the same things over us. We are in a new family.

Jesus looked to his baptism in Gethsemane, and on the cross, to be reassured of his mission. Same is true for us. Defines what we are and what we should do.

This is essential for the nurturing of our children.

It is a sign of corporate membership. It is the union of husband and wife.

Quote from Hodge on baptismal efficacy based on Eph 5:26. The benefits of redemption comes through baptism in the same way that they come through the word of God - as it is received in faith. Baptism is a seal of the benefits on condition of repentance and faith. What ever has ben enjoyed before, this is the public conveyance of the benefits.

3. At his baptism, Jesus was ordained into priestly service.
Two bits of information: Matthew - to fulfil all righteousness; Luke - about 30 years of age.

John’s baptism based upon Mosaic law - levitical background. Three reasons for cleansing - leprosy, contact with a corpse, priestly consecration.

Leprosy and corpse - Jesus baptism signaled the need of resurrection of Israel. These gathered into a new baptism - Christian. Death no longer has the upper hand.

John’s baptism meant partial ordination. Water and oil were used in OT for priests. John only used water. But Jesus receied the ‘oil’ of the spirit. He became a priest of the order of Melchizedek.

Our baptisms are ordinations into the new priesthood. We are washed with pure water (Heb 10:20) and we cross over th sea into the heavenly place through baptism.

Such thinking about ordination is found in the early, medieval, and reformation Christians.

Waht value is this ordination to us? Matthew’s account mirrors the Exodus. Jesus is the new Moses. We are the priesthood to be light to a dark world. We care for one another to maintain purity, We call the world to the repentance and faith. We conduct missions of mercy.

Baptism shows the temporal nature of the relationship we are in. We are trusting a person not a set of propositions. Baptism is not just theological but practical. We become integrated into the eternal relationship between Father Son and Holy Spirit - ontology. But also eschatology - several lines of OT thought converging on the baptism of Jesus.

Through our baptism the Father adopts us - efficacy.

Categories: ,

Categories: Uncategorized